/fix — Fix-Review Loop

Resolve FIX-FIRST gaps from /review. Dispatch a fix subagent, re-review, repeat up to 2 loops, then escalate.

When to Use

• /review returned a FIX-FIRST verdict with CRITICAL or HIGH gaps
• Orchestrator hands off unresolved gaps after execution review

Flow

1. Parse gaps: extract gap list from FIX-FIRST verdict — severity, files, failing checks.
2. Dispatch fixer: send gaps + original wish criteria to fix subagent.
3. Re-review: dispatch review subagent to validate the fix against the same pipeline.
4. Evaluate verdict:

5. Escalate (if needed): mark task BLOCKED, report remaining gaps with exact files and failing checks.

Escalation Format

Fix loop exceeded (2/2). Escalating to human.
Remaining gaps:
- [CRITICAL] <gap description> — <file>
- [HIGH] <gap description> — <file>

Dispatch

Fix and re-review must be separate dispatches — never combine them in one subagent.

# Spawn a fixer subagent
genie agent spawn fixer

# Spawn a reviewer subagent (separate from fixer)
genie agent spawn reviewer

Task Lifecycle Integration (v4)

When a PG task exists for the work being fixed, log each fix attempt as a task comment:

Graceful degradation: If no PG task exists for the work being fixed, skip all genie task commands. Fix loop logging is an enhancement — the fix flow must never fail due to missing tasks.

Example

/review returned FIX-FIRST with 2 gaps:

- [CRITICAL] workDispatchCommand missing initialPrompt — dispatch.ts:532
- [HIGH] protocolRouter.sendMessage result not checked — dispatch.ts:541

The orchestrator runs /fix:

# Loop 1: dispatch fixer with gaps
genie agent spawn fixer
genie agent send 'Fix these gaps from /review on wish fix-dispatch-initial-prompt:
- [CRITICAL] dispatch.ts:532 — add initialPrompt to handleWorkerSpawn
- [HIGH] dispatch.ts:541 — check protocolRouter.sendMessage result, log warning on failure
Reference: qa-runner.ts:334 shows correct pattern.' --to fixer

# Wait for fixer to complete
sleep 60 && genie agent log fixer --raw

# Re-review (separate subagent — never the same as fixer)
genie agent spawn reviewer
genie agent send 'Review wish fix-dispatch-initial-prompt. Check the fixer changes against acceptance criteria. Run bun test.' --to reviewer

# Reviewer returns SHIP → done
# If FIX-FIRST again → loop 2 (max 2 loops, then escalate)

Rules

• Never fix and review in the same session — always separate subagents.
• Never exceed 2 fix loops — escalate, don't spin.
• Include original wish criteria in every fix dispatch.
• If identical gaps persist across loops, escalate immediately — no progress means BLOCKED.