Comprehensive Code Review

Run a thorough review using ALL 30 review checklists via the senior-review-specialist agent.

Instructions

Spawn the senior-review-specialist agent to perform this review.

Checklists to Apply

Load and apply ALL of these review checklists:

Correctness & Logic

• commands/review/correctness.md - Logic flaws, broken invariants, edge-case failures
• commands/review/backend-concurrency.md - Race conditions, atomicity, locking, idempotency
• commands/review/refactor-safety.md - Semantic drift, behavior equivalence

Security & Privacy

• commands/review/security.md - Vulnerabilities, insecure defaults, missing controls
• commands/review/infra-security.md - IAM, networking, secrets, configuration
• commands/review/privacy.md - PII handling, data minimization, compliance
• commands/review/supply-chain.md - Dependency risks, lockfiles, build integrity
• commands/review/data-integrity.md - Data correctness over time, failures, concurrency

Architecture & Design

• commands/review/architecture.md - Boundaries, dependencies, layering
• commands/review/performance.md - Algorithmic efficiency, N+1 queries, bottlenecks
• commands/review/scalability.md - Load handling, dataset growth, multi-tenancy
• commands/review/api-contracts.md - Stability, correctness, consumer usability
• commands/review/maintainability.md - Readability, change amplification
• commands/review/overengineering.md - Unnecessary complexity, YAGNI violations

Infrastructure & Operations

• commands/review/infra.md - Deployment config, least privilege, operational clarity
• commands/review/ci.md - Pipeline security, deployment safety
• commands/review/release.md - Versioning, rollout, migration, rollback
• commands/review/migrations.md - Database migration safety
• commands/review/reliability.md - Failure modes, partial outages
• commands/review/logging.md - Secrets exposure, PII leaks, wide-events
• commands/review/observability.md - Logs, metrics, tracing, alertability
• commands/review/cost.md - Cloud infrastructure cost implications

Quality & Testing

• commands/review/testing.md - Test quality, coverage, reliability
• commands/review/style-consistency.md - Codebase style, idioms
• commands/review/docs.md - Documentation completeness and accuracy

User Experience

• commands/review/accessibility.md - Keyboard, assistive technology, ARIA
• commands/review/frontend-accessibility.md - SPA-specific accessibility
• commands/review/frontend-performance.md - Bundle size, rendering, latency
• commands/review/ux-copy.md - User-facing text clarity, error recovery
• commands/review/dx.md - Developer experience, onboarding

Agent Instructions

The agent should:

1. Get working tree changes: Run git diff to see all changes
2. For each changed file:
   • Read the full file content
   • Go through each diff hunk
   • Apply ALL 30 checklists to the changes
   • Trace problems to their root cause
3. Cross-reference related files: Follow imports, check callers
4. Find ALL issues: Be thorough, expect to find many issues

Output Format

Generate a comprehensive review report with:

• Critical Issues: Blocking problems (must fix)
• Warnings: Should address before merge
• Suggestions: Improvements to consider
• File Summary: Issues per file with counts by severity
• Overall Assessment: Ship/Don't Ship recommendation with rationale